Appraisal Summary Table 3

Benefit Cost Ratio Sensitivity Testing

Complete the following table for all core options as a summary of the results of the sensitivity testing undertaken. The Appraisal Guidelines refer to seven types of area of uncertainty to test:

 Capital costs

 Construction duration and therefore opening date

 Operating (including maintenance) costs

 Under and over estimation of the benefits (typically demand for the service)

 Changes in global oil prices

 Fluctuations in carbon prices; and

 Different population growth/decline scenarios and set out the value of each benefit for each forecast year. 

Additional sensitivity tests are recommended on key parameters, such as the annualisation factors or the value of travel time adopted.  Worst case scenarios should also be tested (costs +30%, benefits -30%).

Sensitivity test #

Variation

Benefit-Cast Ratio (BCR)

0

 Starting result

....

1

 Discount rate 4%

....

2

 Discount rate 10%

....

3

....

....

4

....

....

5

....

....

etc

Etc

....