Project
Sponsor
(e.g., state
DOT, toll
authority)

Consultants and legal/financial
advisors contracted by
project sponsor

Private
Investors
bidding on
the project

Interest groups

Media (e.g., newspaper, TV, blogs)

This
information
is not
available

Terms of agreement

12 
27.3%*

12 
27.3%

10 
22.7%

5 11.4%

4 
9.1%

1
 2.3%

Experience/qualification of proposers

10 
22.7%

11 
25.0%

10 
22.7%

3 
6.8%

4 
9/1%

1 
2.3%

Risks transferred from and retained by public sector

13 
27.3%

10 
22.7%

8 
18.2%

3 
6.8%

2 
4.5%

2 
4.5%

Evaluation of benefits/disbenefits to public sector

12 
27.3%

12
 27.3%

4 
9.1%

3 
6.8%

3 
6.8%

2 
4.5%

PPP valuation studies (e.g., benefit-cost analysis, value-for-money analysis/public sector comparators, traffic and revenue studies) provided by in-house staff or consultants

12 
27.3%

13 
29.5%

5 
11.4%

2 
4.5%

2 
4.5%

1 
2.3%

Project cost estimates and schedule

12 
27.3%

11 
25.0%

9 
20.5%

3 
6.8%

3 
6.8%

1 
2.3%

Amount of upfront payment/revenue sharing (if long-term concession)

9 
20.5%

9 
20.5%

9 
20.5%

2 
4.5%

2 
4.5%

4 
9.1%

Assumptions used by private investors to determine project value

6 
13.6%

9 
20.5%

6 
13.6%

1 
2.3%

1
2.3%

4 
9.1%

Technical approach

12 
27.3%

11 
25.0%

11 
25.0%

3 
6.8%

2 
4.5%

1 
2.3%

Other (specify in "Additional Comments" box below):

1 
2.3%

-

-

-

-

9 
20.5%