While providing a variety of advantages, there are also risks to consider when using PPPs for transportation projects. The many categories of project risks are listed below in Exhibit 2.7.
Exhibit 2.7 Types of Risks Associated with Transportation Infrastructure Project PPP
• Demand/volume • Revenue • Environmental/archeological • Regulatory/contractual • Payment structure/mechanism • Transaction cost • Construction cost • Maintenance cost • Life-cycle cost • Liability/latent defects | • Compensation and termination clauses • Changes of law • Economic shifts • Currency/foreign exchange • Taxation constraints • Moral hazard • Loss of control of assets • Political stability • Protectionism • Public acceptance |
Beginning on the next page, Exhibit 2.8 indicates potential consequences of a number of these key risk factors for members of a PPP and suggests ways to mitigate these results. Several of these risk categories are discussed in more detail following Exhibit 2-8.
Exhibit 2.8 Consequences and Mitigation Strategies for Major Types of PPP Project Risks
Risk Category | Description | Consequence | Mitigation |
Site Conditions | • Existing • Contamination • Necessary | • Additional • Clean up costs. | • Commission studies • Private sector to |
Design, | • Facility incapable • Physical or | • Increase in • Delayed/lost | • Seek reputable • Private party may • Link payments to |
Financial | • Interest rate risk. • Financing • Contingent | • Increased • Non - | • Interest rate hedging. • Financial due • Bank/capital |
Operating | • Inputs, • Changes to | • Increase in • Adverse effects | • Long-term supply • Upfront specification |
Market | • Fluctuations in • Competition, | • Lower revenues. • Diminution in | • Private operator to seek • Review likely |
Legislative | • Additional • Changes in laws | • Further • Increase in operating costs with regards to complying with new laws | • Private sector to • Public sponsor may |
Asset Ownership | •· Loss of the facility upon premature termination of lease or other project contracts upon breach and without adequate payment. • Different residual value to that originally calculated | • Loss of • Possible service | • Private party will be • Public sponsor may • Impose on the private • Secure services of a |