Collection of information

 6    We collected information from the following main sources:

  the documentation issued to bidders during the project procurement phase;

  the detailed proposals of the three shortlisted bidders before the award of contract;

  interviews with members of the joint DSS and Benefits Agency/Post Office procurement team, including officials and advisers, on how they handled the specification of the service and the negotiation of the deal;

  the legal agreements and schedules underpinning the purchasers' contract with Pathway;

  the project management documentation of the Joint Benefits Agency/ Post Office Counters Ltd' Delivery Authority during the implementation phase;

  risk management documentation, particularly risk registers and reports, raised during both the procurement and implementation stages of the project.

  scrutiny of the reports of successive external reviews of the project and interviews with authors of these reports where we required clarification;

  a visit to a post office operating the Card payment system prior to its cancellation; and

  interviews with each of the three short-listed bidders, including Pathway, who also made available to us selected project documentation, demonstrated to us the operation of the system, and shared with us lessons they have learned.

 7   We also searched the internet, using search engines, for international evidence on Information Technology project outcomes.