Question 86 (Mr Sadiq Khan): Can we have a note of the experts that were used and how much they cost.

Paddington Health Campus

INFORMATION ON USE AND COSTS OF ADVISERS TO THE PROJECT

Line

Topic

Company

Service

Appointed

Total
expenditure

1

legal

Berwin Leighton Paisner

PHC legal adviser

May 2002

£759,060

2

legal

Capsticks

One-off advice

May 2001

£4,250

3

Corporate finance

Pricewaterhouse Coopers

PHC corporate finance advisers

Oct 2002

£583,480

4

Corporate finance

Ernst & Young

Interim advice on risk and tariff

Jan 2001

£29,680

5

Healthcare planning

Office for Public Management

Interim training on PFI process

2001

£18,480

6

Healthcare planning

P Adams Consultancy

Consultancy support to Process Development Groups

2001

£21,500

7

Healthcare

Agenda

Review of planning

 

 

 

planning

 

assumptions

Nov 2002

£32,860

8

Healthcare

Sigma HB

Revision of OBC activity

 

 

 

planning

 

assumptions

April 2001

£99,190

9

Healthcare

Mike Hartfield

International

 

 

 

planning

 

benchmarking

Sep 2004

£8,210

10

Healthcare

IHG

Private Patients study

 

 

 

planning

 

 

2001

£12,690

11

NHS finance

Mike Flaxman Associates

NHS Finance modelling

2000

£459,860

12

Healthcare

Secta

Healthcare advisers to

 

 

 

planning

 

PHC

Mar 2003

£128,990

13

Healthcare planning

Finnamores

WLPF appointment

 

£34,130

14

Healthcare planning

Newchurch

OBC support

 

£318,890

15

Technical

BDP

Interim technical advice

June 2002

£93,850

16

Technical

Sheppard Robson

architectural adviser to PHC

Mar 2003

£112,160

17

Technical

Durrow Management

Planning advice

 

£10,410

18

Technical

Turner Townsend

Project advice to Imperial College

 

£105,000

19

Technical

King Sturge

Due diligence report on the Point

Nov 2003

£35,270

20

Technical

DLE

Cost consultancy

2002/3

£508,740

21

Technical

Studio 4

Architectural adviser to PHC

Apr 2003

£154,290

22

Technical

IBS

Technical adviser to PHC

Apr 2003

£871,330

23

OBS

Virginia de Vere

Space planning

Oct 2001

£83,600

24

FM Support

Healthgain

FM consultancy

2001

£10,300

25

FM Support

DD Associates

Strategic equipment advice

2001

£2,900

26

FM Support

IBS

Interim FM adviser

May 2002

£44,380

27

FM Support

EC Harris

Interim Soft FM adviser

Feb 2003

£25,000

28

FM Support

EC Harris

Soft FM adviser

June 2003

£60,590

29

Decant

Love Jenkins

Decant costing

2000

£1,750

30

Decant

Studio 4

Architectural advice on decant and planning

Apr 2003

£279,440

31

Decant

TBA

QEQM condition survey

Jan 2001

£23,260

32

Decant

Hornagold and Hills

Project management and business case support

Oct 2002

£146,380

33

IM&T

Silicon

IM&T support to OBC

 

£15,850

34

IM&T

Saba/DQS

IM&T PHC advisers

2001

£105,760

35

IM&T

Health Systems

 

2003

£1,510

36

IM&T

Pagoda

Infrastructure advice

2002

£46,190

37

Property

Derek Horne

Planning Brief advice

Nov 2000

£9,920

38

Property

Insignia Richard Ellis

Property advice on Post Office site

2003

£24,360

39

Property

Weatheralls

Point AcquisitionandPDCL land valuation

May 2003

£136,650

40

Property

District Valuer

Valuation of land deals

Aug 2003

£9,360

41

Property

Montagu Evans

Land sales valuation

Sep 2002

£122,760

42

Communications

Jonathan Street

Interim PR advise

Dec 2002

£18,730

43

Communications

Jonathan Street

PR support

Jun 2003

£8,600

44

Communications

Christows

Communications adviser to PHC

Aug 2003

£144,010

45

Communications

London Communications

Communications adviser

 

 

 

 

Agency

to PHC

Nov 2004

£49,490

46

PCO support

EC Harris

Set up electronic control office

Dec 2002

£78,920

47

Audit

Deloitte + Touche

External auditors to both Trusts

On-going appointment

£32,000

48

Audit

Parkhill Audit

Internal auditors to PHC

Jointly appointed by both Trusts

£38,930

49

Equipment

MTS

Estimate of PSC equipment cost

Nov 2002

£16,600

50

Equipment

UMG

Equipment adviser to PHC

Mar 2003

£77,540

51

Insurance

Willis

Insurance adviser to PHC

Oct 2003

7,680

52

Accommodation

Hunters

Staff accommodation strategy

2000

£24,710

53

Town Planning

Savell Bird & Axon

Transport planning

2000

£80,220

54

Town Planning

Gordon IngramAssociates

Daylighting and rights to light

2000

£35,780

55

Town Planning

SOM

Planning application

2000

£923,560

56

Town Planning

SOM

Post application support

July 2000

£114,350

57

Town Planning

GLHearn

Planning consultancy

1998

£217,340

58

Town Planning

Ove Arup

Environmental consultants

2000

£141,570

59

Town Planning

Terry Farrell & Partners

Masterplanning

July 2004

£181,700

60

Town Planning

TGA

Engineering investigation

2000

£5,030

61

Town Planning

Virtual Artworks

Visual assessment images

2001

£14,750

62

Town Planning

Museum of London Archaeology Service

Architectural heritage study

2002

£6,380

63

Other

various

Sundry items

 

£20,640