The census did not try to judge whether PFI was the best procurement route for these projects

2.37  Our census focused on the post-contract construction experience of departments' and agencies' PFI projects involving the construction of a built asset, which was complete or due to be complete by summer 2002. In this report we have not set out to examine the value for money of the original deals for these projects. In particular, we have not examined the price which departments have paid to secure the risk transfer which has generally been achieved in the PFI construction projects surveyed. We have examined these wider aspects of value for money in previous reports on individual PFI building projects or groups of projects (Figure 12).

12

 

PFI deals including built assets previously reported on by the National Audit Office

 

 

Report title

Number

Report Title

Number

 

 

The Skye Bridge

HC5, Session 1997-98

DSS, Newcastle Estate

HC16, Session 1999-00

 

 

Bridgend and Fazakerley Prisons

HC253, Session 1997-98

The First Four DBFO Roads

HC476, Session 1997-98

 

 

A74(M)/M74 DBFO Road

HC356, Session 1998-99

Dartford and Gravesham Hospital

HC423, Session 1998-99

 

 

Royal Armouries Museum in Leeds

HC103, Session 2000-01

The Berlin Embassy

HC585, Session 1999-00

 

 

Redevelopment of MOD Main Building

HC748 Session 2001-2002

MOD: The Joint Services Command & Staff College

HC537 Session 2001-2002

 

 

The PFI contract for the redevelopment of West Middlesex University Hospital

HC 49, Session 2002-03

 

 

2.38  In addition, we have not sought to judge how well the construction element would have been performed had these contracts been let using the other procurement methods outlined above, drawing on the initiatives and improvements which have been generally adopted in the construction industry in recent years. However, the generally positive results of the projects in our census compare favourably with the historical experience of public sector procurement of other construction projects.