Weight

Bidder 1 - Std

Bidder 1- VB1

Bidder 1 - VB2

Bidder 2 - Std

Bidder 2 - VB1

Bidder 2 - VB2

Bidder 3 - Std

Bidder 3 - VB1

Bidder 3 - VB2

%

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

(1)

(2)

Service Delivery and Technical

Method Statement 1 -

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Method Statement 2 -

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Method Statement 3 -

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Method Statement 4 -

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Method Statement 5 -

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Method Statement 6 -

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

Method Statement 7 -

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

Method Statement 8 -

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

Method Statement 9 -

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

Method Statement 10 -

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

10

3.00%

Method Statement 11 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 12 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 13 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 14 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 15 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 16 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 17 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 18 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 19 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Method Statement 20 -

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

10

2.00%

Total for Service Delivery and Technical

60.00%

60.00%

60.00%

60.00%

60.00%

60.00%

60.00%

60.00%

60.00%

60.00%

Financial and Commercial

Overall Costs, Affordability and Value for Money

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Financial and Economic Standing of the Consortia

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Financial Robustness of the Bid

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Deliverability of the Funding Package

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Total for Financial and Commercial

20.00%

20.00%

20.00%

20.00%

20.00%

20.00%

20.00%

20.00%

20.00%

20.00%

Legal and Contractual

Extent to which Bid meets the Local Authority's expectations

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Commercial Robustness

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Ability to support the Model Contract

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Total for Legal and Contractual

15.00%

15.00%

15.00%

15.00%

15.00%

15.00%

15.00%

15.00%

15.00%

15.00%

Overall Integrity

Consistency of technical, financial and legal proposals

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

10

5.00%

Total for Overall Integrity

5.00%

5.00%

5.00%

5.00%

5.00%

5.00%

5.00%

5.00%

5.00%

5.00%

Total Score for Bid

100.00%

100.00%

100.00%

100.00%

100.00%

100.00%

100.00%

100.00%

100.00%

100.00%