ISDS evaluation scores

Corporate and Transactional Services Procurement Pack - ISDS evaluation framework

	Weight	Bidder 1 - Std		Bidder 1- VB1		Bidder 1 - VB2		Bidder 2 - Std		Bidder 2 - VB1		Bidder 2 - VB2		Bidder 3 - Std		Bidder 3 - VB1		Bidder 3 - VB2
	%	Raw score	Weighted score	Raw score	Weighted score	Raw score	Weighted score	Raw score	Weighted score	Raw score	Weighted score	Raw score	Weighted score	Raw score	Weighted score	Raw score	Weighted score	Raw score	Weighted score
Service Delivery and Technical
Method Statement 1 -	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Method Statement 2 -	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Method Statement 3 -	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Method Statement 4 -	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Method Statement 5 -	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Method Statement 6 -	3.00%	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00
Method Statement 7 -	3.00%	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00
Method Statement 8 -	3.00%	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00
Method Statement 9 -	3.00%	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00
Method Statement 10 -	3.00%	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00	10	3.00
Method Statement 11 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 12 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 13 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 14 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 15 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 16 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 17 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 18 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 19 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Method Statement 20 -	2.00%	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00	10	2.00
Total for Service Delivery and Technical	60.00%		60.00		60.00		60.00		60.00		60.00		60.00		60.00		60.00		60.00
Financial and Commercial
Overall Costs, Affordability and Value for Money	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Financial and Economic Standing of the Consortia	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Financial Robustness of the Bid	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Deliverability of the Funding Package	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Total for Financial and Commercial	20.00%		20.00		20.00		20.00		20.00		20.00		20.00		20.00		20.00		20.00
Legal and Contractual
Extent to which Bid meets the Local Authority's expectations	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Commercial Robustness	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Ability to support the Model Contract	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Total for Legal and Contractual	15.00%		15.00		15.00		15.00		15.00		15.00		15.00		15.00		15.00		15.00
Overall Integrity and Best Value
Consistency of technical, financial and legal proposals	5.00%	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00	10	5.00
Total for Overall Integrity and Best Value	5.00%		5.00		5.00		5.00		5.00		5.00		5.00		5.00		5.00		5.00
Total Score for Bid	100.00%		100.00		100.00		100.00		100.00		100.00		100.00		100.00		100.00		100.00

Notes	Instructions
Std = standard bid	1. Agree weighting of main criteria (Service & Delivery, Financial and Commercial, Legal and Contractual, Overall Integrity and Best Value)
VB1 = variant bid 1	2. Agree weighting of sub-criteria (e.g. method statement 1)
VB2 = variant bid 2	3. Score each sub-criteria out of 10 (see scoring criteria overleaf)