Section 3  Business & Operational Impact Assessment

Assess the P3 potential of the project in terms of business and operational impacts using the following criteria:

Technical

  Does the project have any inherent technical constraints that cannot be solved by a private/not for profit sector partner?

  Can the public sector develop appropriate performance/output specifications for the project?

  Can appropriate mechanisms be established to monitor the private/not for profit sector partner's performance?

  How will the bundling of design, build and operate result in expedited completion of the capital asset and reduced costs?

  Can payment and/or revenue be tied to performance?

  Does the project offer opportunities for innovation by a private sector partner?

  Is the project free of jurisdiction and liability issues that prevent a public body from using a P3 approach?

Operational

  Can a public sector organization develop appropriate operating standards for the project?

  Are there any operational and accountability issues that cannot be realistically addressed by a private/not for profit sector partner?

  Can the private/not for profit sector partner be held accountable for appropriate performance?

Acceptability

  Is there potential for objections to the use of a P3 approach and the involvement of a private/not for profit sector partner in the project by the public, elected officials, public sector staff, unions or other stakeholders?

  Where applicable, is the use of a P3 supported by the Supported Infrastructure Organization (SIO)?

Implementation

  Does the private sector have the expertise to deliver?

  Is there sufficient interest in the private sector to generate meaningful competition in P3 procurement?

  Can a fair, accountable and transparent selection process by used?

  Can an internal project champion be found?

  Can the project champion access the resources necessary to be a competent partner?

  Can a successful transition plan be developed?

Timing

  Are the timelines adequate to develop operating specifications, contract documents and to undertake a P3 solicitation and evaluation?

  Can the issues raised in the items above be addressed in the project timelines?