Evidence-based qualitative assessment 

While the impact assessment scores are qualitative, they are evidence-based.

Our analysis is complemented by examining detailed studies, pilots and deployments of the proposed reforms domestically and in other jurisdictions. This evidence is set out in the forthcoming detailed plans for each sector and cross-sector, which will be released after the 2021 Plan to provide further evidence to support our case for reform. 

Evidence for long-term reforms is often qualitative or circumstantial, but we encourage and support change agents to undertake more detailed and quantitative assessments as part of implementing the reforms. 

Table IV.3 shows how the scoring and use of evidence will be presented in the detailed plans.

Table IV.3: Criteria are supported by justifications and evidence

Impact criteria

Score

Justification

Evidence

'Minimises upfront and ongoing costs'

Qualitative scale, as per Table IV.2

Provides a qualitative justification for the Impact assessment score that draws on relevant evidence where appropriate

References as evidence that supports the assessment of the criterion